earnrate
vs

Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant American Express vs United Club

Updated Nov 11, 2026 · American Express and Chase · Personal cards

At typical U.S. spending, the Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant American Express earns more: about −$393 a year after its $650 annual fee, against −$405 for the United Club after its $695 annual fee. That's $12 a year more.

See where they rank on your spending

Who each card suits

Rates by purchase

PurchaseMarriott Bonvoy Brilliant American ExpressUnited Club
Groceries1%1%
Dining1.5%2% (earns more)
Gas1%1%
Travel1%2% (earns more)
Amazon1%1%
CostcoNot accepted1% (earns more)
Everything else1%1%
4 more purchases
PurchaseMarriott Bonvoy Brilliant American ExpressUnited Club
Flights1.5%2% (earns more)
Transit1%2% (earns more)
Marriott3% (earns more)2%
United Airlines1.5%5% (earns more)

What each purchase earns back, with each card set up at its best for it (the right bonus pick, any activation done, no cap used up yet). The higher rate is highlighted. Costco takes only Visa in-store.

Fees

Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant American ExpressUnited Club
Annual fee$650 a year$695 a year
Foreign transaction feeNoneNone
Membership neededNoneNone

Public welcome offers

Yours may differ: issuers test and target offers, so use the one shown to you when you apply.

How this is calculated

Typical spending here is $23,880 a year (a month: groceries $500, dining $250, gas $150, Amazon $100, streaming (Netflix) $40, flights $60, hotels $60, other travel $30, cell phone $115, TV and internet service $95, transit $25, drugstores $40, everything else $525), each card used on its own for everything, with its best bonus picks. Points are counted at 0.5¢ each for Marriott Bonvoy points and 1¢ each for United MileagePlus miles, what they're worth as cash or travel credit; transferring them to airlines or hotels can be worth more. If you'd use all the Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant American Express' statement credits and free night (up to $725 a year: restaurants and anniversary free night), it nets up to $332 a year. If you'd use all the United Club's statement credits ($790 a year: Instacart, JSX, rideshare and taxis, Renowned Hotels and Resorts (Chase Travel)), it nets $385 a year. They're worth that only if you'd spend at those places anyway, and a free night only on a stay you'd make anyway, at a hotel that costs its full point cap.

From the issuers' terms

Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant American Express Card

Checked against American Express' terms Nov 3, 2026.

  • “1 additional point (for a total of 3 points) for each dollar charged at restaurants worldwide” americanexpress.com
  • “for airfare on a scheduled flight charged directly with passenger airlines (charter flights and private jet flights are excluded)” americanexpress.com
  • “6X points at hotels participating in Marriott Bonvoy®” americanexpress.com
  • “You will receive 2 Marriott Bonvoy® points for each U.S. dollar of eligible purchases charged” americanexpress.com
  • “Foreign Transaction None Penalty Fees” americanexpress.com

United Club Card

Checked against Chase's terms Nov 1, 2026.

Each card in full

Typical spending, point values and fees come from earnrate's data, and every rate from the issuers' terms. Rates change; check each issuer's terms before you apply.